Merging IO and Either into one monad

Posted on September 2, 2019 by Riccardo.

A good way to metabolize new concepts is to copy ideas from other people and try to make them compile. This is exactly what we are going to do today.

In case you wanted to read the (better) original, please check out “A Gentle Introduction to Monad Transformers”.

The Problem

Let’s write a function to extract the domain from an email:

getDomain :: Text -> Either LoginError Text
getDomain email =
  case T.splitOn "@" email of
    [_, domain] -> Right domain
    _           -> Left InvalidEmail

Then let’s say we want to ask the user for their email and use the domain as a token for authentication:

getToken :: IO (Either LoginError Text)
getToken = do
  T.putStrLn "Enter email address:"
  email <- T.getLine
  pure $ getDomain email

Besides the token, the user need to input a password. The database of users is the following:

users :: Map Text Text
users = Map.fromList
  [ ("example.com", "qwerty123")
  , ("localhost", "password")
  ]

For our authentication system three possible errors are possible:

data LoginError
  = InvalidEmail
  | NoSuchUser
  | WrongPassword
  deriving (Show)

Finally, we can put all together:

userLogin :: IO (Either LoginError Text)
userLogin = do
  token <- getToken
  case token of
    Right domain ->
      case Map.lookup domain users of
        Just password -> do
          T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
          pw <- T.getLine
          if pw == password then
            pure $ Right domain
          else
            pure $ Left WrongPassword
        Nothing ->
          pure $ Left NoSuchUser
    left    ->
      pure $ left

And we are done!

Nope, it’s a joke. That piece of code really is ugly. We need to do something about it.

There’s one secret to clean up userLogin: the indentation comes from the fact that we are dealing with two different monads (i.e. IO and Either).

Let’s see if merging the two into one solves our issue.

The Solution

We first wrap the two monads into EitherIO:

data EitherIO e a = EitherIO {
  runEitherIO :: IO (Either e a)
}

Then we define instances for Functor, Applicative and Monad:

instance Functor (EitherIO e) where
  -- fmap :: Functor f => (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  -- fmap g f = EitherIO $ fmap (fmap g) (runEitherIO f)
  fmap g = EitherIO . fmap (fmap g) . runEitherIO

-- THIS IS NOT LAWFUL. DO NOT USE FOR SERIOUS STUFF!
instance Applicative (EitherIO e) where
  -- pure :: a -> f a
  pure = EitherIO . pure . Right
  -- (<*>) :: f (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  fg <*> f = EitherIO $ liftA2 (<*>) (runEitherIO fg) (runEitherIO f)

instance Monad (EitherIO e) where
  -- (>>=) :: forall a b. m a -> (a -> m b) -> m b
  m >>= mg = EitherIO $ (runEitherIO m >>= either (pure . Left) (runEitherIO . mg))

We can define getToken in terms of our new monad:

getToken' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
getToken' = do
  EitherIO $ fmap Right (T.putStrLn "Enter email address:")
  email <- EitherIO $ fmap Right T.getLine
  EitherIO $ pure $ getDomain email

Even better, we can create a couple of helpers to make it cleaner

liftEither :: Either e a -> EitherIO e a
liftEither = EitherIO . pure

liftIO :: IO a -> EitherIO e a
liftIO = EitherIO . fmap Right

getToken'' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
getToken'' = do
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter email address:"
  email <- liftIO T.getLine
  liftEither $ getDomain email

Now, userLogin can be rewritten as:

userLogin' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  case Map.lookup domain users of
    Just password -> do
      liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
      pw <- liftIO T.getLine
      if pw == password then
        liftEither $ Right domain
      else
        liftEither $ Left WrongPassword
    Nothing ->
      liftEither $ Left NoSuchUser

We have removed one level of nesting. That is because with the Monad instance of EitherIO, we “extract” the domain with <- getToken'' and not the Either _ domain as before. But we can do even better:

userLogin'' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin'' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  password <- maybe (liftEither $ Left NoSuchUser) pure $ Map.lookup domain users
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
  pw <- liftIO T.getLine
  if pw == password then
    liftEither $ Right domain
  else
    liftEither $ Left WrongPassword

With all of that in place we can run the login with:

main :: IO ()
main = do
  result <- runEitherIO getToken''
  print result

But wait, there’s more!

We could refactor userLogin to:

throwE :: e -> EitherIO e a
throwE = liftEither . Left

userLogin''' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin''' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  password <- maybe (throwE NoSuchUser) pure $ Map.lookup domain users
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
  pw <- liftIO T.getLine
  if pw == password then
    liftEither $ Right domain
  else
    throwE WrongPassword

But if we can throw, we can also catch:

catchE :: EitherIO e a -> (e -> EitherIO e a) -> EitherIO e a
catchE throwing handler = EitherIO $ do
  result <- runEitherIO throwing
  case result of
    Left  e -> runEitherIO $ handler e
    success -> pure success

And have a handler that allows the user to retry the login in case of WrongPassword error:

wrongPasswordHandler :: LoginError -> EitherIO LoginError Text
wrongPasswordHandler WrongPassword = do
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Wrong password, one more chance."
  userLogin'''
wrongPasswordHandler e = throwE e

With that we can:

main :: IO ()
main = do
  result <- runEitherIO $ userLogin''' `catchE` wrongPasswordHandler
  print result

The whole code

{-# LANGUAGE OverloadedStrings #-}

module Main where

import Data.Text as T
import Data.Text.IO as T
import Data.Map as Map
import Data.Either (either)
import Data.Maybe (maybe)
import Control.Applicative (liftA2)

data LoginError
  = InvalidEmail
  | NoSuchUser
  | WrongPassword
  deriving (Show)

getDomain :: Text -> Either LoginError Text
getDomain email =
  case T.splitOn "@" email of
    [_, domain] -> Right domain
    _           -> Left InvalidEmail

getToken :: IO (Either LoginError Text)
getToken = do
  T.putStrLn "Enter email address:"
  email <- T.getLine
  pure $ getDomain email

users :: Map Text Text
users = Map.fromList
  [ ("example.com", "qwerty123")
  , ("localhost", "password")
  ]

userLogin :: IO (Either LoginError Text)
userLogin = do
  token <- getToken
  case token of
    Right domain ->
      case Map.lookup domain users of
        Just password -> do
          T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
          pw <- T.getLine
          if pw == password then
            pure $ Right domain
          else
            pure $ Left WrongPassword
        Nothing ->
          pure $ Left NoSuchUser
    left    ->
      pure $ left

data EitherIO e a = EitherIO {
  runEitherIO :: IO (Either e a)
}

instance Functor (EitherIO e) where
  -- fmap :: Functor f => (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  -- fmap g f = EitherIO $ fmap (fmap g) (runEitherIO f)
  fmap g = EitherIO . fmap (fmap g) . runEitherIO

-- THIS IS NOT LAWFUL. DO NOT USE FOR SERIOUS STUFF!
instance Applicative (EitherIO e) where
  -- pure :: a -> f a
  pure = EitherIO . pure . Right
  -- (<*>) :: f (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  fg <*> f = EitherIO $ liftA2 (<*>) (runEitherIO fg) (runEitherIO f)

instance Monad (EitherIO e) where
  -- (>>=) :: forall a b. m a -> (a -> m b) -> m b
  m >>= mg = EitherIO $ (runEitherIO m >>= either (pure . Left) (runEitherIO . mg))

getToken' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
getToken' = do
  EitherIO $ fmap Right (T.putStrLn "Enter email address:")
  email <- EitherIO $ fmap Right T.getLine
  EitherIO $ pure $ getDomain email

liftEither :: Either e a -> EitherIO e a
liftEither = EitherIO . pure

liftIO :: IO a -> EitherIO e a
liftIO = EitherIO . fmap Right

getToken'' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
getToken'' = do
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter email address:"
  email <- liftIO T.getLine
  liftEither $ getDomain email

userLogin' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  case Map.lookup domain users of
    Just password -> do
      liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
      pw <- liftIO T.getLine
      if pw == password then
        liftEither $ Right domain
      else
        liftEither $ Left WrongPassword
    Nothing ->
      liftEither $ Left NoSuchUser

userLogin'' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin'' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  password <- maybe (liftEither $ Left NoSuchUser) pure $ Map.lookup domain users
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
  pw <- liftIO T.getLine
  if pw == password then
    liftEither $ Right domain
  else
    liftEither $ Left WrongPassword

throwE :: e -> EitherIO e a
throwE = liftEither . Left

userLogin''' :: EitherIO LoginError Text
userLogin''' = do
  domain <- getToken''
  password <- maybe (throwE NoSuchUser) pure $ Map.lookup domain users
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Enter password:"
  pw <- liftIO T.getLine
  if pw == password then
    liftEither $ Right domain
  else
    throwE WrongPassword

catchE :: EitherIO e a -> (e -> EitherIO e a) -> EitherIO e a
catchE throwing handler = EitherIO $ do
  result <- runEitherIO throwing
  case result of
    Left  e -> runEitherIO $ handler e
    success -> pure success

wrongPasswordHandler :: LoginError -> EitherIO LoginError Text
wrongPasswordHandler WrongPassword = do
  liftIO $ T.putStrLn "Wrong password, one more chance."
  userLogin'''
wrongPasswordHandler e = throwE e

main :: IO ()
main = do
  print $ getDomain "a"
  print $ getDomain "a@b"
  t <- getToken
  print t
  result <- userLogin
  print result
  t' <- runEitherIO getToken''
  print t'
  t'' <- runEitherIO $ userLogin''' `catchE` wrongPasswordHandler
  print t''

I need your help to make the blog awesome. Here's a survey. Since there are no required questions, you decide how much time to spend on it.

Support my work by tweeting this article! 🙏

Starting from the Problem not the Solution

I spent most of the day in solution space. The wrong solution space. In fact, I was solving a problem that didn't exist.

Rewriting to Haskell–Intro

Hidden in the Functional Programming basement at Lunar Logic we want to have fun, enable newcomers to approach Haskell and creating future options for the company

Rewriting to Haskell–Deployment

Everything needed to deploy and run Stream (Servant) on the server side